Moorfields Eye Hospital Oxford Eye Hospital Massachusetts Eye Institute

Case 2: Answers

Editors:

Prof Dr CHUA Chung Nen, Dr. NGO Chek Tung, Dr Ting Siew Leng and Dr. Koay Chiang Ling

This patient underwent double eyelid surgery (Asian blepharoplasty).


a. How does the upper eyelid of the East Asians differs from that of the Caucasians?

The eyelids of the East Asian differ from the Caucasians in the following ways:
• Upper eyelid skin crease: In East Asian, the skin crease is lower or non-existent. This is explained by two anatomical differences in the East Asians:
i. The orbital septum fuse with the levator at a lower level resulting in the presence of orbital fat in the upper eyelid that prevent strong adhesion between the levator and the upper eyelid.
ii. Absence of strong natural adherence between the front of the tarsal plate and the back of the skin created by fibrous connections that pierce the orbicularis muscle.
• Upper eyelid fullness: The Asian upper eyelid appears fuller or puffier than the Caucasians because in the former there is downward extension of the orbital fat, a weaker orbital septum, an eyebrow fat pad that is thicker and projects lower into the eyelid and a much thicker subcutaneous fat layer below the skin.
• Epicanthal fold: The presence of a small crescent of skin between the inner eyelid corner and the nose in the East Asians. This is usually absent in Caucasians.
• Eyelashes: The eyelashes of East Asians tend to point downward whereas the eyelashes of the Caucasians tend to point upward or horizontally.
• Tarsal plate: The Asian plate tends to be shorter.
• Vertical palpebral aperture: Asians have the widest vertical palpebral aperture at the junction between medial and middle third. In the Caucasians, the widest vertical palpebral aperture is at the centre of the lid.


b. What are the two main methods of creating an upper eyelid skin crease in East Asians?

Suture method and the incision method.
The principle of the suture method is based on the development of adhesions or cicatricial changes between the skin and deeper tissue that are induced by the suture material. The advantages of this method are that it is simple to perform and the patient recovers faster. The ideal candidates are young people with taut skin with relatively little or no orbital and submuscular fat as this method does not remove the orbital fat. The main disadvantage of this technique is that the skin crease is more likely to disappear than one created using the incisional technique.
In the incisional method, the skin crease is created at a desirable height through removal a sliver of skin and the orbicularis oculi. And depending on the degree of puffiness, the orbital fat may be removed. The skin crease is created by skin-levator-skin suture.

 

c. What are the main complications of Asian blepharoplasty?

The most common complications are:
• Asymmetrical eyelid skin creases. This results from unequal skin crease marking prior to surgery.
• Excessively high or low skin creases. This results from inappropriate skin crease markings.
• The skin crease is too short or discontinuous. This is usually caused by inadequate adhesion between the skin and the levator.
• Multiple skin creases and this is usually related caused by the creation of a skin crease which is too high.
• Supratarsal depression from excessive removal of orbital fat.

Reference:
Chen SH, Mardini S, Chen HC, Chen LM, Cheng MH, Chen YR, Wei FC, Weng CJ. Strategies for a successful corrective Asian blepharoplasty after previously failed revisions. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2004 Oct;114(5):1270-7.

ye Hospital.